Football Tactics for Beginners- The False Winger

A relatively new one to the lexicon of the footballing world, the false winger is often associated with players that drift inside to make...
Ritesh Gogineni
Editor/Founder of The False 9. Inverted Wingers,Carilleros,Cattenacio,Double Pivots,Medianos,Mezzalas and of course The False Nines we have got it all here for the tactic-crazy football fan!

Latest Posts

Man City 3:0 Arsenal Tactical Analysis- The Master vs The Apprentice

When Mikel Arteta was an assistant of Pep Guardiola at Manchester City, they not only dominated England but were one of the best teams...

How will Pjanic fit in at Barcelona? A look at Barcelona’s 4-3-3 formation for next season

As the deal between Barcelona and Juventus regarding the transfers of Arthur Melo and Miralem Pjanic has almost been finalised, let's take a look...

A look at Nigel Pearson’s tactics at Watford

4/12/2019, Leicester City Stadium. Watford suffers yet another defeat, and the ominous bells of relegation are echoing louder at Vicarage Road. The board had...

Great Squads From History – Bayer Leverkusen 2001-2002

The 2001-02 great Bayer Leverkusen side is infamous for their incredible choke job in the last stretch of the season, losing out on three...

How will Arthur fit in Juventus’s midfield: Sarri’s thrilling 4-3-1-2 formation

Sky Sports News has confirmed that Juventus and Barcelona have agreed upon a £72.5m fee for the signing of midfielder Arthur. The Brazilian midfielder...

The Man of Ten Thousand Voices

A young man graciously welcomes me into a room radiated with TV screens, computers, control panels, and flashing LEDs.  A small group of men...

A Tactical Look at how Marseille qualified for the Champions League

After a 7 year exile from Europe’s elite competition, the club from the south of France has finally restored their Champions League status by...

Football Books

Best Football Analytics Books

We have compiled a list of the best football analytics books for the casual football fan. Football analytics and data science/machine learning in general...

The Best Football Books of 2019

It's been another eventful year in the world of football. As we look forward to 2020, we have compiled a list of the best...

The Best Football Books of 2018

It's been another eventful year in the world of football. As we look forward to 2019, we have compiled a list of the best...

5 Books every Soccer fan needs to read before the FIFA World Cup 2018

The FIFA World Cup is just around the corner and it's the perfect time to brush up your history and facts about the World...

Best Soccer Coaching Books

We have compiled a list of the best soccer coaching books which every soccer coach must have in his/her bookshelf. No matter whether you...

Andy Carroll, the £35M Throwback?

We welcome Tom Nash to The False Nine,who has written this brilliant piece on Andy Carroll,hopefully this is the first of many!

 
When the dust had barely settled after the deadline day whirlwind of January 2011, the biggest question mark hung over Liverpool’s £35M acquisition of Newcastle forward Andy Carroll. Here was a player with just one senior cap for England, who had enjoyed only half a season in the English top flight, and before Newcastle’s promotion season the year before, had hardly been prolific in the Championship. Chelsea’s £50M splurge on Fernando Torres has been widely criticised since then, with the Spaniard looking woefully short of form and confidence, but there is always the old adage of “class is temporary, form is permanent” to fall back on, which has been trotted out by football journalists and Chelsea fans ever since. There is a feeling that Torres would inevitably come good, perhaps a summer break and intensive pre-season with the Blues will bed him in nicely and he would resume his intelligent runs, get back his poaching instinct, and once more terrify defences throughout England and Europe. Luiz Suarez already looks like great business, and perhaps because of the Uruguayan’s instant impact, and the fact that Carroll’s own debut was delayed for such a long time due to an injury, the jury is still well and truly out on Andy Carroll. So, what has Kenny Dalglish got for Fenway Sports Group’s money?


Described as a typical English number nine, Andy Carroll offers Liverpool a number of options tactically.
Kenny Dalglish’s tactics have historically involved variations on the 4-4-2, best seen during his previous tenure at Liverpool, and his title winning stint at Blackburn. Parallels have been drawn between Dalglish’s purchase of Carroll, and Alan Shearer’s move to Blackburn. Liverpool fans must be hoping he makes half the contribution that Shearer did in the mid-nineties. Dalglish himself enjoyed playing in this formation, alongside Ian Rush, and Liverpool are noted for their front two partnerships – Keegan and Toshack, Beardsley and Aldridge, Owen and Heskey.
So, it is easy to fit Andy Carroll into a 4-4-2, perhaps better described as a 4-4-1-1, with Luis Suarez as a tricky support striker alongside Carroll, in his favoured centre-forward position. However, the formation is widely derided as being out of date these days, and few top teams employ this tactic. England’s pitiful performance at the 2010 World Cup has been blamed on the rigidity of their 4-4-2, and it’s inability to cope with more modern, fluid formations.
Few would argue that Carroll lacks the physicality and positional sense required for being played up front on his own. A 4-5-1 certainly looks like a possibility, as Liverpool continue to stock up on central midfield players – they now have Gerrard, Meireles, Lucas Leiva, Spearing and Henderson all vying for position, and continue to be linked with a move for Charlie Adam. Three of those five/six would make for quite a formidable central midfield. Henderson is also able to play on the right, so a choice between him and a resurgent Dirk Kuyt could be one of King Kenny’s dilemmas for the coming season. Another player linked with a transfer to Anfield is Aston Villa’s Stewart Downing, who can play on either wing, and it’s very easy to slot him into this formation too. Against superior opposition and European away games, a 4-5-1 is a definite possibility – but can Dalglish justify dropping Suarez? In my opinion, a Chelsea style 4-5-1/4-3-3 is the most likely formation for Liverpool to play with any regularity. A front three of Suarez-Carroll-Kuyt certainly looks good on paper, Kuyt having the discipline and energy required to track back when Liverpool aren’t in possession. Steve Clarke’s influence on tactics shouldn’t be underestimated, and he was supposedly brought in as Dalglish’s number two for his tactical nous and modern methods. His loss is felt at Chelsea more so than Ancelotti’s departure.
 
As Mourinho’s assistant, Steve Clarke will know this formation inside out, will know the players needed to make it work, and would know how to coach the players to thrive in it.
If rumours are to be believed, Liverpool are currently sniffing around Gael Clichy, who would suit both the typical 4-4-2 favoured by Dalglish – using full-backs to give width, and the 4-3-3 employed by Steve Clarke and Mourinho at Chelsea a few years ago – which also relies on the full backs bombing forward. Clichy on the left and Glen Johnson on the right certainly has lots of attacking potential, and should ensure Liverpool fans get their wish of attacking football granted.
Of course, football isn’t played in lines anymore (someone should tell England manager Fabio Capello) and it’s the fluidity and movement of modern formations such as Barcelona and the Spanish national team – the current benchmark for all things great and wonderful – which may show Carroll up to be a little limited. In a modern formation such as 4-1-3-2, 4-1-4-1, or 4-2-3-1 players need to be able to interchange to find space and confuse the opposition’s markers. Whilst it’s easy to see Andy Carroll as a very effective spearhead for these formations, it’s more difficult to imagine him switching to the wing, or dropping deep into midfield to turn and face goal as a trequartista, or false nine. He just hasn’t displayed the inventiveness or vision to make him anything other than a target man.
Looking back over the last 7 years, only two teams have won the Champions league playing with a traditional centre-forward in the mould of Andy Carroll. In 2007, AC Milan played a 4-4-1-1 with the quintessential number nine Pippo Inzaghi in that role, and in 2009 Jose Mourinho’s Internazionale beat Bayern Munich fielding Diego Milito up front on his own in a 4-2-3-1. Both men were over 30 when they played in those games. So whilst it’s probably unfair to consign the centre-forward role to the scrapheap on those statistics, it does illustrate that fewer of the top teams have an out-and-out target man these days. If Barcelona are to continue to sweep all before them with a formation that employs no recognised centre-forward, that trend will only continue.
No centre-forward has won the FIFA World Player of the Year since Ronaldo in 2002, and aside from Fabio Cannavaro, all other winners have been attacking midfielders, wingers, and strikers.
So, whilst Andy Carroll could be used as a focal point for many different formations, he is unlikely to be as adaptable and interchangeable as those winning major awards and trophies, which may leave Liverpool lagging behind the top teams.
That said, tactics and formations evolve to enable teams to beat pre-eminent sides, they are responsive and organic. Perhaps Kenny Dalglish and Steve Clarke have sat down and concluded that the way to beat these possession based, passing teams is to put a big guy up front. Andy Carroll is, as discussed, not able to interchange as much as most other attacking players, but if he does what he’s paid for, he can leave that to the rest of his team. It’s also a disservice to Carroll to infer from his positional monogamy that his link up play isn’t good – it is. From 19 games for Newcastle in the Premiership, he scored 11 times and provided 6 assists. That’s good returns in anyone’s book for a mid-table club.Also his passing is very good and unlike other “big man” center forwards he comes deep to collect the ball at times.
 
Carroll’s passing against Man United and Arsenal
 
 He certainly is a nuisance to play against. He’ll provide an exit route for when Liverpool have possession but are under pressure. There’s not many defenders who fancy a 50/50 aerial battle with him, and perhaps in this regard, his reputation off the field may even help him intimidate defenders. There are other strong centre-forwards in the English Premier League, notably Kevin Davis, Emile Heskey, Drogba, and Kenwyne Jones. Aside from Drogba, who’s best is clearly past him, none of the others score with any regularity. A centre-forward who scores goals shouldn’t be a rarity, but they are these days. Which is why – as any first year Economics student can tell you – he cost so much.
Far from the finished article, Carroll will surely develop more as a player under the tutelage of Dalglish and Clarke than he might have done at Newcastle, and his future career is one of the most eagerly anticipated in England.
Provided he makes a concerted effort to keep himself on the back pages rather than the front (Although the predatory nature of the British press ensure that they now circle like sharks round a bloodied seal), and provided that Liverpool continue to sign and retain players who will give him the service he needs, there is every chance that Carroll can be the man who can buck the current tactical trends, and lead Liverpool back up to their perch. 30 goals a season should be a target
So, Andy Carroll – £35M throwback? Yes, but that might not be a bad thing.Tom Nash

- Advertisement -
Ritesh Gogineni
Editor/Founder of The False 9. Inverted Wingers,Carilleros,Cattenacio,Double Pivots,Medianos,Mezzalas and of course The False Nines we have got it all here for the tactic-crazy football fan!

Related

Zola To Leave Chelsea This Weekend As Kovacic Returns

Italian football legend, Gianfranco Zola is set to leave Chelsea this weekend following the expiry of his contract with the blues. Zola served as...

A look at Gian Piero Gasperini’s tactics at Atalanta

After almost 3 years with Gian Piero Gasperini at the helm of Atalanta, they finished 3rd in the Serie A this season, securing European...

Who are the Five Most Tactically Astute Managers in Europe Right Now?

Millionaire superstar players may have endless social media followers, may score the goals, drive the fancy cars and have their names appear on the...

The rise of Luka Jovic

By now even the most casual of football fans will have heard about him, while Football Manager enthusiasts have known about him for years...

The Football Transfer Sources Reliability Guide

The modern day football fan has access to unlimited amount of information about their favorite player, club or team. Especially when it comes to...

Anthony Martial Form Changed Mourinho’s Plans

  Jose Mourinho was planning on bringing in Ivan Perisic from Inter to Manchester United when the transfer window was going to open, however, his...

3 wingers better than Ivan Perisic Mourinho can buy this summer for Man United

Manchester United and Inter Milan have not been able to come to an agreement with regards to the sale of Ivan Perisic. Jose Mourinho's...

Man United expected starting lineup against Man City: Mourinho to continue the 3-5-2 experiment

Manchester United face their first real test of their pre-season tour against Manchester City on Thursday at the NRG Stadium in Houston, Texas. Both United...

Latest Posts

Man City 3:0 Arsenal Tactical Analysis- The Master vs The Apprentice

When Mikel Arteta was an assistant of Pep Guardiola at Manchester City, they not only dominated England but were one of the best teams...

How will Pjanic fit in at Barcelona? A look at Barcelona’s 4-3-3 formation for next season

As the deal between Barcelona and Juventus regarding the transfers of Arthur Melo and Miralem Pjanic has almost been finalised, let's take a look...

Three best Premier League transfers of all time

The Premier League is famous for its lavish spending on player’s transfers. Top clubs like Liverpool, Manchester City, and Manchester United have been spending...

A look at Nigel Pearson’s tactics at Watford

4/12/2019, Leicester City Stadium. Watford suffers yet another defeat, and the ominous bells of relegation are echoing louder at Vicarage Road. The board had...

Don't Miss

How to beat Pep’s Barcelona, with helpful advice from Bruce Lee, Samuel Johnson, and others.

Barcelona have started to dominate European football to such an extent that the drawing of group stages was inconsequential to them being pronounced favourites...

How Pep Guardiola’s Barcelona Reinvented Total Football

Arrigo Sachi, the mastermind of the Milan side of the 80′s, had once staked a claim that the next tactical revolution in the game,...

Hungary – The Golden Team that never quite made it.

When you look back at the history of past World Cup winners and European Championship winners the usual names by in large stand out....

English Football and its “Get Stuck-In” Mentality

It was a glum group of players and supporters who filed out of Matlock Town’s Causeway Lane ground in 1982. Hyde United had lost...

Lifted Over The Turnstiles: Scotland’s Football Grounds In The Black & White Era

This most comprehensive book about old Scottish football grounds ever published, Lifted Over the Turnstiles contains almost 200 photos of 42 football stadiums here...

Transfers

How will Pjanic fit in at Barcelona? A look at Barcelona’s 4-3-3 formation for next season

As the deal between Barcelona and Juventus regarding the transfers of Arthur Melo and Miralem Pjanic has almost been finalised, let's take a look...

Three best Premier League transfers of all time

The Premier League is famous for its lavish spending on player’s transfers. Top clubs like Liverpool, Manchester City, and Manchester United have been spending...

Where will Kai Havertz play for Chelsea? A look at Lampard’s exciting 4-2-3-1 formation for next season

There have been several rumours surrounding Kai Havertz's transfer to Chelsea and Havertz's current boss, Peter Bosz has indicated that the winger might not...

Man United expected lineup against Sheffield United: Pogba & Bruno to start together for first time

Manchester United salvaged a draw against Tottenham in their first game post the lockdown. Their performance improved after the substitutions of Paul Pogba and...

How will Arthur fit in Juventus’s midfield: Sarri’s thrilling 4-3-1-2 formation

Sky Sports News has confirmed that Juventus and Barcelona have agreed upon a £72.5m fee for the signing of midfielder Arthur. The Brazilian midfielder...