The Fuss about the 4-2-3-1

So what’s this fuss about 4-2-3-1? Why do people think that a formation can change the fortune of a team like England.Well the most widely used formation in international football is 4-2-3-1 and the top clubs in Europe have been using variations of 4-2-3-1 over the past decade,except of course the English clubs until recently,preferred the classic 4-4-2.In a tactical sense, England is way behind Spain as the Spaniards adopted the 4-2-3-1 as early as 2000.  English pundits still regard playing 5 in midfield as defensive and is not looked upon kindly in the Premier League.
4-2-3-1(Red) Vs 4-4-2(Blue)

The Evolution
The trend of making their second striker as the play maker emerged in the 1986 world cup,the most famous example being Maradona himself. Once more and more teams started adopting this– the coming of 4-2-3-1 was inevitable.  So then teams played a holding mid player to pick up the playmaker and the striker up lone used to drift into wide areas,leaving space in the middle,so to prevent that there were two holding midfield players and there was born the Double Pivot. And slowly but surely teams realised the importance of having possession and not being over run in the midfield and many turned to the 4-2-3-1.  Of course every manager and every team had their own interpretations of this system.
The Double Pivot
The efficiency and the compactness that the double pivot provides makes it vital to have in the modern game. The double pivot actually is the usage of two holding mid-fielders in front of the defence.  One generally more creative than the other and is termed as the “Deep Lying  Playmaker“.  All the 4 semifinalists at the 2010 World Cup used the double pivot.  Spain,Holland and Germany all made their own interpretations of the 4-2-3-1 whereas Uruguay played with a classic 4-4-2 but unlike England whose Central Midfielders had to go forward and support their strikers,the Uruguayan central midfielders stayed back and acted as a double pivot.  This statistic shows the importance of the double pivot and it is here to stay in the modern game.  Actually the use of double pivot depends lot on the two players involved as in a double pivot each player doesn’t have a definite role, either of them can stay back and either of them can make a forward run depending on the situation.  But the roles may vary from team to team.
Real Madrid:
Xabi Alonso-Deep Lying Playmaker
Sami Khedira-Defensive Mid
The Netherlands:
Van Bommel & De Jong-Both Defensive Mids
Song & Wilshere-Both box to box midfielders
The most important role and generally the best player is the attacking midfielder or the advanced playmaker.He has to have great vision,creativity,the ability to see a pass and generally should have a good finish too.Wesley Sneijder(Netherlands,Inter), Xavi(Spain), Fabregas(Arsenal), Ozil(Madrid,Germany) are accomplished players who perform this role effectively.There are two important tactical points to be noted here
  1. The CAM, because he plays between the lines or as one can say between the defense and the midfield, can get the opposition into a conundrum.  He drags either a center back or one of the pivots from out of his position.
  2. If the CAM drops deep then it helps the team to retain posssession which is what one has to do when playing teams like Barcelona,this also prevents your midfield from getting overrun.
The False 10
We all know about the false 9(a striker who drops deep to create space for other players to exploit),but in the World Cup there emerged a new tactic-the false 10.  The false 10′s break forward from deeper parts of the pitch to exploit the gaps created in the opposition defence by the false nine’s movement. Sneijder,Ozil and Keisuke Honda perfomed this role quite admirably.  But the man who is master of this role is Lionel Messi for Argentina(By the way he is an excellent false 9 for Barcelona).

Wesley Sneijder’s average position in the game against Denmark

Mesut Ozil’s average position against Australia
As you can see both Ozil and Sneijder’s positions are quite same as their striker’s, so this proves the theory of the false 10.
Variations of the 4-2-3-1
There have been a number of variations of the 4-2-3-1 by manager of various clubs and international sides.  Lets look at some of them.
The Strikerless formation
The strikerless formation or the 4-6-0 was perfected by Sir Alex Ferguson in the 2007-08 season, here the front three i.e Rooney,Ronaldo and Tevez used to drop into midifield and then depending on the situation took turns to play as the striker.  The ability of all the three player to either play on the wings or up front meant that SAF could use this tactic to a great effect.  Although United used it to great effect and won the Double that season,  Roma under  were the ones who initially perfected it.
Dunga’s 4-2-3-1
Dunga’s Brazil was not very popular back home,as they were looked up as a defensive minded unit not playing the samba-style football their fans are used to seeing.  Europeans viewed Brazil’s formation as a 4-2-3-1 with Gilberto and Melo as the pivots, Ramires(or Elano),Kaka and Robinho supporting the lone forward Luis Fabiano.But the Brazilians insisted on describing their system as a diamond.  They saw Gilberto as the base,Melo on the left and Ramires on the right as carrileros (the shuttlers on both the edges of the diamond),Kaka as the tip of the diamond(Play  maker) and Robinho as the second striker.As we can see below both the views are correct.

The diamond as the South Americans see it

The 4-2-3-1 as the Europeans view it
Mourinho’s 4-2-3-1
Jose Mourinho adopts a defensive approach in his 4-2-3-1(Real Madrid,Inter) by using 2 holding midfielders and basing the attack on a disciplined counter attack.  He used it to great effect at Inter and it a work in progress at Real.
How does one play against the 4-2-3-1?
The easiest way to play against a side playing 4-2-3-1 would be to play 4-2-3-1 ourselves.  But if the opposition is of higher quality then we would stand no chance.The W-W formation is an effective way to combat the 4-2-3-1.The W-W which Barcelona have mastered recently was actually used in the 1930s, as they say history does repeat itself.

The W-W formation
Whatever the tactical system is the players who are on the pitch have to perform,but having said this the modern game is increasingly being played out in the mind especially the internationals where the difference in the quality of teams is minute.

Read More

A look at Chris Wilder’s tactics at Sheffield United

It is perhaps no coincidence that the two in-form English managers were honing their craft in the Championship a year before, they now sit...

The Forgotten story of the Basque in South America

This article is sourced from a string of Twitter posts by Impedimento, translated by the author. Exactly 80 years ago, a French steamer called SS...

Manchester United’s biggest transfer mistake of last summer

Manchester United's disastrous run under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer starting after their famous victory in Paris can be explained due to a multitude of factors....

The tactical flexibility of Ralph Hasenhuttl’s Southampton:

  Hasenhuttl has certain areas of the first team’s play that he wants to improve before the Premier League kicks-off again in August. Having arrived...

How will Manchester City lineup in the 2019/20 season

Pep Guardiola will be looking to repeat on last year’s success and win the Premier League title for a third straight year. The Manchester...

Manchester City and the art of tactical fouling

Manchester City beat West Ham United 5-0 in their first game of the new season as the champions showed no signs of letting their...

Mason Mount: Chelsea’s Golden Boy

When Frank Lampard was appointed, Derby County fans everywhere collectively held their breath in the hope of whom his widely spoken about “contacts” might...

Football Tactics for Beginners

Football Tactics for Beginners: Tactical Periodization

What is Tactical Periodization? Tactical Periodization is a coaching methodology which is used to train football players with respect to the tactical context of the...

Football Tactics For Beginners:The Box to Box Midfielder

The Box to Box Midfielder and its decline. The Box to Box midfielder is a term which is used to describe a midfielder who influences...

Football Tactics for Beginners: Defending Corner Kicks

We are all afraid of it. It is the 90th minute, your team is up by one goal and the opposition is about to...

Football Tactics for Beginners-The Regista

The rapid rise of the 4-2-3-1 formation over the past decade has seen the importance of the regista or the deep lying playmaker skyrocket....

Football Tactics For Beginners- The 4-4-2 Diamond Formation

The 4-4-2 Diamond formation. Introduction. Whilst the traditional 4-4-2 formation has become less common in recent years, the diamond variation is alive and well. The differences...

Football Tactics for Beginners: The Makelele Role

Very rarely are football terms named after the footballers themselves, one example is of course the famousCruyff turn,but the most famous of our generation is “The Makelele Role”. ...

The Diminishing role of the Stopper Center Back in the Premier League

Defending and its place in the modern game has spawned a quagmire of critical debate. Back in 2014, when Gary Neville’s article in the...

Adopting the Right Mindset: How Mental Tactics Can Create Champions

Football is a funny old game and, like all sports, the margins between victory and defeat are often razor thin. In fact, as the...

The Perfect Defensive System #5- Gegenpressing

In this new series called The Perfect Defensive System,we invite you the reader to contribute posts on what you think is the best defensive...